← Back to mind map

Knowledge branch 09 · Seminar 15

Consumer guarantee remedies

Consumer Guarantee Remedies

Classify the failure first

先判断failure严重程度

01

ENGLISH

The remedy pathway begins by asking whether the failure is major, cannot be remedied, or is non-major and remediable. A consumer cannot choose a major-failure remedy merely because repair is inconvenient; the statutory classification controls who chooses the initial remedy and whether rejection or termination is available.

中文解释

救济路径首先判断failure是major、无法补救,还是non-major且可补救。消费者不能仅因维修不方便就选择major failure救济;法定分类决定谁有权选择最初救济,以及是否可以拒收或终止合同。

  • Reasonable consumer would not have acquired had the failure been known合理消费者若事先知道问题便不会购买
  • Significant departure from description, sample or demonstration model与描述、样品或展示模型存在重大偏离
  • Substantially unfit for common purpose and not easily remedied promptly严重不适合通常用途且不能轻易及时补救
  • Unfit for disclosed purpose and not easily remedied promptly不适合披露用途且不能轻易及时补救
  • Unsafe goods or services商品或服务不安全

Goods - ACL ss 259-265

商品救济 - ACL ss 259-265

02

ENGLISH

For a major or non-remediable failure, the consumer may reject the goods and choose refund or replacement, or keep them and recover the reduction in value, plus reasonably foreseeable consequential loss. For a non-major remediable failure, the supplier first chooses an appropriate remedy within a reasonable time; if it refuses or delays, the consumer may repair and recover reasonable cost or reject when statutory conditions are met.

中文解释

对于major或无法补救的failure,消费者可拒收并选择退款或更换,或保留商品并索赔价值减损,同时主张合理可预见的后续损失。对于non-major且可补救的failure,supplier先在合理时间内选择适当补救;若拒绝或拖延,消费者可自行维修并追偿合理费用,或在满足条件时拒收。

  • Rejection is limited by the rejection period, disposal, loss, consumer-caused damage and attachment to land拒收受拒收期限、处分、灭失、消费者造成的损坏及附着土地等限制
  • A connected services contract may be terminated under s 265相关服务合同可依s 265终止
  • Change of mind alone creates no ACL refund right单纯改变主意不会产生ACL退款权

Services - ACL ss 267-270

服务救济 - ACL ss 267-270

03

ENGLISH

For a major or non-remediable service failure, the consumer may terminate and recover the unused portion of the price or retain the contract and recover the reduction in value, together with foreseeable loss. For a non-major failure, the supplier must first be given a reasonable opportunity to remedy; otherwise the consumer may arrange rectification and recover reasonable cost.

中文解释

对于major或无法补救的服务failure,消费者可终止合同并收回未消费部分价款,或保留合同并索赔价值减损,同时主张可预见损失。对于non-major failure,应先给supplier合理补救机会;否则消费者可安排第三方修复并追偿合理费用。

Manufacturer remedies and indemnity

Manufacturer救济与补偿

04

ENGLISH

Direct manufacturer claims under ss 271-272 commonly recover reduction in value and reasonably foreseeable loss, including enforcement of express warranties. A supplier may seek statutory indemnity from the manufacturer under s 274. These routes are distinct from supplier remedies and from Pt 3-5 safety-defect compensation.

中文解释

依ss 271-272直接针对manufacturer的请求通常可获得价值减损及合理可预见损失,并可执行express warranty。Supplier可依s 274向manufacturer请求法定补偿。这些路径不同于supplier救济,也不同于Pt 3-5的safety defect赔偿。

  • Vautin, TPS Developments, Williams v Toyota and Karpic illustrate remedy classificationVautin、TPS Developments、Williams v Toyota及Karpic展示救济分类
  • Repairers must warn about refurbished parts and possible data loss under Reg 91维修商依Reg 91须提示翻新零件及数据丢失风险