← Back to mind map

Knowledge branch 05 · Seminar 9

Unfair contract terms

不公平合同条款

Coverage - ss 23-28

适用范围 - ss 23-28

01

ENGLISH

The unfair-terms regime applies to a consumer contract or small business contract that is standard form. A small business generally has fewer than 100 employees or annual turnover below $10 million. The court first determines coverage before asking whether the particular term is unfair.

中文解释

不公平条款制度适用于采用standard form的consumer contract或small business contract。Small business通常指员工少于100人或年营业额低于1,000万澳元。法院必须先确定合同受制度覆盖,再判断具体条款是否不公平。

Standard form - s 27

格式合同 - s 27

02

ENGLISH

Relevant considerations include relative bargaining power, whether one party prepared the contract before discussion, whether it was offered on a take-it-or-leave-it basis, whether there was a real opportunity to negotiate and whether the terms reflect the other party's circumstances. The statutory presumption places pressure on the party asserting that the contract was negotiated.

中文解释

判断因素包括相对议价能力、合同是否在协商前由一方预先拟定、是否只能接受或拒绝、是否存在真实谈判机会以及条款是否考虑对方具体情况。法定推定会使主张合同经过协商的一方承担说明压力。

The three-limb test - s 24

三要素测试 - s 24

03

ENGLISH

A term is unfair only if it creates a significant imbalance, is not reasonably necessary to protect the advantaged party's legitimate interests, and would cause financial or non-financial detriment if applied or relied on. All three limbs must be satisfied. The court also considers transparency and the contract as a whole.

中文解释

条款只有同时满足三项条件才构成不公平:造成显著权利义务失衡;并非保护受益方合法利益所合理必要;适用或依赖时会造成金钱或非金钱损害。法院还必须考虑透明度及合同整体。

  • The advantaged party bears the burden on reasonable necessity受益方对合理必要性承担举证责任
  • Transparency means plain language, legibility, presentation and ready availability透明度包括语言清晰、可读性、呈现方式及是否容易获得
  • Section 25 gives examples but is not exhaustives 25列举示例但并非穷尽

Exclusions and consequences

排除与后果

04

ENGLISH

Section 26 excludes terms defining the main subject matter, setting the upfront price and terms required or expressly permitted by law. An unfair term is void. Since 9 November 2023, proposing, applying or relying on an unfair term is also prohibited and can attract penalties, compensation and other orders.

中文解释

s 26排除界定合同主要标的、确定预付价格以及法律要求或明确允许的条款。不公平条款本身无效。自2023年11月9日起,提出、适用或依赖不公平条款也属于禁止行为,并可能产生罚款、赔偿及其他命令。

  • ACCC v JJ Richards - broad one-sided standard termsACCC v JJ Richards - 广泛而单方面的格式条款
  • Karpic v Carnival - class-action and consumer-contract questionsKarpic v Carnival - 集体诉讼及消费者合同问题
  • Jetstar v Free - proper identification of the term and contractJetstar v Free - 正确识别条款及合同